Choosing Your Proxy Provider: Smartproxy vs. Bright Data

Among the many prime contenders within the proxy service trade, Bright Data and Smartproxy are distinguished by their complete vary of internet scraping options and capabilities. They’re main internet knowledge platform, providing web scraping API, no-code data collection tools, quite a lot of proxy types with in depth proxy swimming pools.

Each Smartproxy and Shiny Information have their distinctive strengths and purposes. On this article, we are going to evaluate these two internet knowledge companies throughout totally different standards, together with pricing, options, and consumer expertise.

Concerning the suppliers & market positioning

We evaluated the market positioning of the distributors contemplating the overall variety of buyer critiques, the typical score given by these prospects, and the variety of workers at every firm.

The whole rely of buyer critiques and the score knowledge have been sourced from B2B overview platforms resembling G2, Capterra, and TrustRadius, with the knowledge being up-to-date as of November 23, 2023.

Smartproxy

Smartproxy offers a balance of performance and cost-effectiveness. In comparison with different proxy service suppliers focusing on enterprise-level purchasers, Smartproxy gives aggressive pricing. This makes it a viable choice for people customers and smaller companies.

Shiny Information

Shiny Information is an online knowledge platform, providing an in depth vary of options and one of many largest IP swimming pools within the proxy market. Shiny Information serves predominantly enterprise-scale customers that require detailed and location-specific internet knowledge.

Characteristic comparability

Web sites, resembling social media platforms and on-line retail shops, usually make use of adcanced programs for detecting bots. To successfully scrape data from these sites, an alternate proxy resolution, resembling internet unblocker, is critical. Each Shiny Information and Smartproxy present internet unblocker companies to handle this want.

The value vary for a proxy service per GB consists of the price per GB within the starter bundle and the price per GB within the largest bundle. This vary helps to offer an understanding of how pricing varies from essentially the most fundamental to essentially the most complete choices.

Each suppliers provide customizable proxy packages tailor-made to your particular wants and use circumstances. In case your necessities exceed the variety of IP addresses included of their largest normal bundle, you will have the choice to tailor a bundle that features extra IP addresses to fit your explicit utility.

Residential proxies

Under is a comparability desk for residential proxies supplied by Smartproxy and Shiny Information.

Be aware: The precise particulars relating to the proxy pool dimension, rotation choices, free trial availability, and worth vary are sourced from the official web sites of Shiny Information and Smartproxy. These particulars might differ and alter over time.

Datacenter (DC) proxies

*Comprising 1.6 million datacenter proxies, out of which 20,000 are shared datacenter proxies.

**Smartproxy units a hard and fast worth of $0.7 per GB for its Datacenter proxies, and so they provide a bulk low cost for purchases of bigger quantities of GBs. 

*** Worth for Smartproxy’s devoted datacenter proxies, and pricing for these proxies is per IP. 

ISP (Static Residential Proxies) proxies

Cellular proxies

The picture under evaluates Smartproxy and Shiny Information on numerous efficiency parameters. Each internet scraping service suppliers carefully match consumer necessities, with Shiny Information main with a 9.2 score primarily based on 115 buyer responses, in comparison with Smartproxy’s 9.1 rating primarily based on 36 customers’ suggestions.

Determine 1: A fast snapshot of shopper suggestions relating to the online scraping companies offered by Shiny Information and Smartproxy.

Supply: G2¹

Execs and Cons

To evaluate the strengths and weaknesses of Shiny Information and Smartproxy, we obtained consumer critiques from G2 and synthesized them to supply insights into their knowledge scraping companies. The concentrate on critiques from 2023 to make sure the shopper critiques current potential patrons with essentially the most present insights.

Shiny Information execs:

Summarized suggestions on Shiny Information’s companies from 2023 buyer critiques:

• Prospects extremely regard Shiny Information for its reliable proxy companies, velocity, and technical proficiency.
• Constructive experiences with buyer assist and account administration are frequent, together with private contacts like account managers.
• Customers acknowledge quite a few useful options that they sit up for exploring additional.
• Customers discover integrating Shiny Information’s instruments into their pipelines straightforward, even with high-volume each day requests.
• The well-structured datasets facilitate straightforward knowledge retrieval.
• The massive IP pool is a major benefit, enabling knowledge entry from numerous sources whereas avoiding IP blocks.

Shiny Information cons:

Summarized suggestions on Shiny Information’s internet scraping companies from 2023 consumer critiques:

• Some customers discover safety configurations for proxy zones difficult, significantly when IP whitelisting isn’t sensible as a consequence of VPN use, which complicates integration and use of the cloud proxy supervisor.
• There may be restricted IDE assist and documentation for creating customized knowledge collectors, with templates solely catering to particular websites.
• Solutions for enhancements concentrate on enhancing safety, consumer expertise, and DevOps to make sure dependable uptime and to raised evade bot detection by web sites.
• Documentation for integration with instruments like Selenium is discovered to be considerably missing, though the proxy merchandise carry out nicely with Python requests.
• Latest updates to the documentation web page have made it more durable to search out pattern code.

Smartproxy execs:

Summarized suggestions on Smartproxy’s companies from 2023 buyer overview knowledge:

• Customers respect Smartproxy’s huge and numerous vary of proxy servers.
• Smartproxy’s residential proxies are significantly helpful for gathering Search Engine Outcomes Web page (SERP) knowledge.
• The client assist staff is extremely praised for successfully resolving points.
• The onboarding course of, cost choices, browser extension and the proxy administration dashboard are famous for his or her ease of use.
• For search engine optimization app builders, Smartproxy’s SERP scraping API is a major asset. Low fail charge, velocity responsive assist and minimal API downtime.
• Smartproxy is acknowledged for its high-quality proxies at aggressive costs, with customizable subscription choices providing optimum between worth and site visitors.

Smartproxy cons:

Summarized suggestions on Smartproxy’s knowledge assortment companies from 2023 consumer critiques:

• A consumer with a customized plan finds the guide cost of invoices difficult, demanding for extra automated cost choices.
• Whereas Smartproxy’s performance is praised, there’s a want for extra granular management in improvement and enhanced integration capabilities with different instruments, resembling Zapier.
• Utilizing city-specific proxies has a studying curve.
• Customers at present must log into their account to trace remaining requests, wishing a a characteristic to programmatically test this.
• A consumer expresses the necessity for longer session durations, discovering the present 30-minute most restrictive.

Pricing and plans

When evaluating the proxy packages of Smartproxy and Shiny Information, Smartproxy supplies a wider vary of choices, together with packages with smaller GB/IP allocations. This makes them extra appropriate for particular person customers and small-scale initiatives. Alternatively, Shiny Information focuses on customized plans tailor-made to particular wants, for which you’d must contact their gross sales staff.

Smartproxy

• Free trial: For his or her scraping APIs and No-Code Scraper, they provide a one-month free trial that features 3,000 requests. For residential, datacenter, and devoted datacenter proxies, customized trials can be found, however they require details about your organization.
• Refund: Smartproxy gives refunds to prospects who’ve used lower than 20% of their proxy plan’s knowledge site visitors or 1 GB. Within the case of scraping instruments, the refund is relevant if not more than 20% of the plan has been utilized.
• Pay-As-You-Go: Out there for residential and cellular proxies.
• Auto-renewable subscription: Smartproxy makes use of a pricing construction that includes automated month-to-month renewals with added VAT, making funds every month initially of the billing cycle. Rotating proxy plans are billed primarily based on site visitors utilization, static proxies are charged per IP, and internet scraping APIs are charged primarily based on the variety of profitable requests.

Shiny Information

• Free trial: Shiny Information supplies a free trial solely for registered corporations. This trial is relevant to all proxy networks, Net Unlocker, SERP API, and the Net Scraper IDE.
• Each plan wants a minimal month-to-month cost: You need to pay a set quantity every month so long as your account is “energetic.” This cost decides your fundamental utilization restrict: in case you use greater than this quantity, you need to add extra money to proceed utilizing our service.
• Pay-As-You-Go: Permits you to use datacenter, ISP, residential, and cellular networks with out a month-to-month dedication. Nevertheless, in case you select pay-per-IP/devoted kind or GIPs, you’ll be billed for the IPs assigned to your zone.

Transparency assertion

AIMultiple serves quite a few rising tech corporations, together with Shiny Information and  Smartproxy.

Extra on proxy server

For steering to decide on the precise residential proxy service, take a look at data-driven list of proxy providers, and attain out to us:

Find the Right Vendors

1. Compare Bright Data and Smartproxy, G2. Accessed: 11/29/2023